• About Me

    I’m an opinionated Grumpy Old Man. I enjoy the intellectual give and take that goes along with that, but have very little patience for stupid people (Note: there is a big difference between “stupid” and “educated”. Some of the stupidest people I’ve ever met have a PhD…). Beside arguing, I like to build things in almost any media. Right now I’m mostly building in wood, Lego, and a bunch of different electronic media. I teach in a number of different venues - from preschool all the way through graduate school. Subjects range from talmud to neuroscience to engineering.

    For fun, I like to bash people with swords (OK, so they’re made of foam. It’s still fun). Although I spend a lot of my time in a wheelchair, I manage to keep pretty active (Like bashing people with swords). I am a libertarian, and have a hard time finding anything good to say about government or politicians. OK, politicians might make good sausage, but that's about as good as it gets.

    Cope

  • VOTE!

    The question: Sould I use more graphics in my posts? I'm lazy, so I don't use them too o ften. If you think more pics would make the blog better, let me know! Simply let me know - email sphyrnatudevote@gmail.com with your vote!
  • Ask Dr. Science has MOVED

    Dr. Science now has his own Blog, so cruise on over to: http://askdoctorscience.wordpress.com to see what's cooking in the lab!
  • June 2009
    M T W T F S S
    « May   Jul »
    1234567
    891011121314
    15161718192021
    22232425262728
    2930  
  • Meta

Sotomayor: why the minority card is a bad play

warning: majorly politically incorrect content. If you can’t deal, bugger off now.

I haven’t decided yet if I support her nomination or not, and I recognize that it doesn’t really matter. However, there are a few things that have been brought up (out of context or not, as a politician, they count) that deserve addressing.

The biggest is the whole idea of her statements that basically sum up to “I’m a minority, so I bring a minority point of view to my findings”. Couple of points:

  1. Duh. How stupid do you think people are? Of COURSE your upbringing affects your point of view.
  2. DOH! In some cases playing the “I’m a minority” card may make political sense, but be realistic: at the national level, you CAN’T expect your opponents to not use it against you. Major political blunder. (As Sotamayor admitted on tape after making one of the stupid statements.)
  3. Choosing to identify with a minority population, then playing on the differences is divisive, not unifying.

OK, so we all know that Sotamayor is a minority. The question is: why does it matter. Right now, Obama is making a huge effort on his world tour to downplay the differences between national cultures – in a large part in an attempt to undo the damage done by Bush’s “We’re Different, We’re better, Our way is the right way” approach. Personally, I think this is a good thing (Obama, not Bush). By focusing on common interests, we set the stage for cooperation and can set aside our differences (at least for now). This is the real problem that I have with Sotamayor. Instead of taking the approach of “I’m a bit different, but it doesn’t really matter, we’re mostly the same”, her rhetoric seems to be “I’m different, and that difference makes me better”. This is a kickback to the Bush approach, and I find it concerning.

I will be the first to admit that her opponents have done their best to play these statements up, and play them out of context – with a good degree of success. Despite that, the fact that she has even voiced these opinions indicates that there is SOME basis for their running them up the flagpole. Much as I despise Rush Limbaugh, I have to agree with his observation that if a white guy had made equivalent comments, he’d be lambasted, and have absolutely no chance of a political career. As a strong proponent of equality, I think we should apply the same measure to everyone. Separate but equal doesn’t work in schools, and in cases like this it fails too.

I fully expect our supreme court justices to bring their personal background and history to the bench. Only a fool would expect otherwise. However, the whole “I’m a minority, and that makes me special” is worrisome. It may be worrisome enough to justify not confirming her. I would be very surprised if this happens, but I can’t say I would be upset if it did. When selecting Supreme Court justices, I would tend to be very cautiouse, and anyone that even hinted at the opinion that a particular minority (any minority) had a more enlightened point of view, or provided a special insight would move them into “hey wait a minute” category. Personally, I would prefer my Supreme Court Justices to be solidly in the “Yeah. This person Works” category….

Advertisements

One Response

  1. I don’t fault Sotomayor for the rhetoric; it’s a product of the culture (as you rightly pointed out). It’s going to take a few generations to get beyond the divisiveness that has pervaded our culture since… well, since just about forever. I think that Obama and the messages that he is trying to put forward are a good first step to that paradigm shift, but it’s going to take a while for “yeah, we’re different, but so what” attitude to take hold.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: